“Follow Your Leader” – Herman Melville’s “Benito Cereno”


I’ve never been a big fan of the traditional mystery genre. I have certainly read some books that were good mysteries, but the exercise of reading with the intent of determining “whodunit” doesn’t appeal to me as the best way to spend my reading time. This bias of mine does not apply, however, to a certain class of novel that is something akin to a mystery. I’m speaking of novels in which the reader is from the start cast into unknown circumstances and must be patient as things are slowly revealed to him. Herman Melville’s novella “Benito Cereno” is such a novel – or I guess technically a novella, as it checks in at only about 75 pages.


I first read Benito Cereno back in 1992, together in a volume along with several other of Melville’s shorter works. The other two I still remember are “The Encantadas” and “Bartleby the Scrivener” (the latter of which I’ve posted about previously). I remember way back then being confused by Benito Cereno, and when I recently re-read it I could easily see why. It’s a mystery of sorts, not so much of a whodunit as a “whodunwhat.”

Based on “actual events” in the early 1800’s, Melville’s story was published in serial form in 1855, and it should be read with the historical context of that time in mind. A time when the struggle between anti- and pro-slavery forces was nearing the fever pitch that culminated in the U.S. Civil War. The story is of an American sea captain, Amasa Delano, at a remote port in southern Chile. While there, a nearly derelict Spanish vessel, the San Dominick is spotted, erratically making its way into the harbor. Delano takes a small boat out to encounter it, possibly to offer assistance, and there meets its captain, the eponymous Benito Cereno.

On board, Delano is met by a rag-tag crew featuring both Spaniards and African slaves. All are nearly starving and beg for supplies. Clearly something is not quite right in this unusual social amalgam. Delano, however, struggles to grasp what might be amiss. An extremely frustrating character, many things are obvious to the reader long before they are to Delano, who continues to take Cereno and his black servant, Babo, at their word when, to most, suspicion and a skeptical reaction would seem to be the order of the day. There is undoubtedly some great writing along the way in the book, as the truth is slowly revealed, and Melville also deftly handles a great, climactic scene that kept this reader on the edge of his seat.

I feel, however, that, since I’ve labeled this work a mystery of sorts, I shouldn’t reveal the details of the true story of the San Dominick. I will reveal the source of the “Follow Your Leader” quote from the title of this post, though. When Delano first boards the ship, he notices that the figurehead on the ship’s prow is covered with canvas and only the ship’s inscription “follow your leader” is visible. Check the illustration above to see what lay hidden under the canvas…

Have you read Benito Cereno, or other shorter works by Melville? What did you think of them?

Benito Cereno may be read for free online at http://www.esp.org/books/melville/piazza/contents/cereno.html

It is also one of many available audiobooks free via the “Free Audio Books” app for the iPhone/iPad.

(Below:  from Wikipedia)



  1. Dale said,

    February 17, 2014 at 8:45 pm

    This is on my DMI list this year. I don’t always look and see how long the stories are. If it’s included in something that says “and other stories”, I assume they are short. And I guess it is short compared to a novel. I’m interested in reading it. Wonder when I’ll pick it?!


    • Jay said,

      February 20, 2014 at 1:10 pm

      Hi Dale,

      I remembered being a little surprised when I saw the Melville stories on your list, as I don’t think any of them are that short 🙂

      I accidentally had a sixty-pager on my list one year. I’ve tried to be more careful in the selection process since then.



  2. hkatz said,

    February 21, 2014 at 12:10 am

    This sounds intriguing; I’ll have to add it to my to-read list.

    Sometimes I like straightforward whodunits. But usually, a mystery story has to have another angle to draw me in. Some study in character, some new locale or ethical issue or something that’s more than just putting together clues.

    I used to watch Law and Order, years ago when Jerry Orbach was still alive and on the show, and I liked how a lot of times there were interesting issues related to law, ethics, and personal relationships (plus the actors inhabited the characters well). I never got into CSI, because a lot of it just seemed like interchangeable people using gadgets to pick up on clues here and there.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. February 23, 2014 at 12:09 pm

    I prefer detective stories to whodunnit’s myself.

    I admire both Billy Budd and Bartleby. I made it through the first 100 pages or so of Moby Dick but never got any further. I’ve seen this one here and there, wasn’t it included in the ARt of the Novella series a few years ago. I may even have a copy lying around somewhere.

    BTW, I will have another Deal Me In post up tomorrow. I am loving your little challenge. I’m already planning for my second deck of stories.


    • Jay said,

      February 23, 2014 at 12:19 pm

      Billy Budd is one of my favorites. I “forced” myself to read Moby Dick years ago and, when I discovered I liked it, then read a bunch of Melville’s shorter stuff afterward.

      Glad you’re liking the DMI challenge. This is my fourth year doing it now. It quickly becomes a habit to read a story a week. & I’m enjoying it so much more this year now that there are several others doing it also.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: